Erie Auto Insurance Reviews

Impressed by low rates, knowledgeable agent

by Nancy

Needed to find new insurance when we moved here and I thought I was getting a good deal with Progressive until I went to the Erie office here and my record is pretty good. I loved the rate and very happy I found them! (Haven’t filed a claim and hope I never do!)

Coverage: 5 Cost: 5 Customer Service: 5 Claims: 2

Fastidious but worth it if you make the cut.

by Kenneth

One thing people should know about them is that they won’t insure just anyone. They are rather selective as a friend of mine was recently turned down. Quick note about him though is he is a lousy driver but my agent said they can beat anyone else is because they take on less risk so they pay out less on claims and in turn give savings to good drivers like us and their rates easily best the usual big boys. They have a lot of discounts (more than what I saw anywhere else) and our rates were for 12 months Read More

Coverage: 5 Cost: 5 Customer Service: 5 Claims: 3

Tested the waters but nobody touched Erie’s rates

by Brent

Since my rate was for a year I didn’t really have to think about it but as my renewal date was coming up I went online out of curiosity to see if I could save with another company. After my fourth check it really wasn’t worth it. I just accepted it that these guys are too good to leave.

Coverage: 5 Cost: 5 Customer Service: 5 Claims: 4