Looked and searched and finally I found AIG.

It wasn’t how I thought to spend my weekend but after calling everyone in the book I finally found these guys! Gotta give them props for the ease of the website and they were very much cheaper and better coverage. I don’t know if this was the cheapest but after I got my quote it was good enough for me to stop searching. I was with my previous insurer for 5 years so they were good enough price-wise to make me switch. Don’t regret it either. Had a hit and run in the supermarket and they helped us quickly.

AIG Auto Insurance Ratings  by Jorge Submit Review | More Reviews

Coverage:
5 out of 5
Cost:
4 out of 5
Customer Service:
4 out of 5
Claims:
5 out of 5